Your WooCommerce thank you page is costing you money
Table of Contents
Your order confirmation page is probably doing nothing. Most WooCommerce stores treat it like a dead end: “Thanks for your order. Here’s your receipt. Goodbye.”
That’s a mistake worth thousands of dollars. Tens of thousands. Hundreds.
The thank you page captures customers at a unique psychological moment. They’ve already trusted you with their money. Their payment details are entered. They’re feeling good about their purchase. And research from Bain & Company, Harvard Business Review, and multiple platform studies shows they’re dramatically more likely to buy again right now than at any other point in the customer journey.
One-click post-purchase upsells convert at 4.7% on average, with top performers hitting 28%, according to ReConvert’s analysis of 40,000+ Shopify merchants. Order bumps convert at 37.8% per Focus Digital’s 2025 study of 1,847 businesses. Meanwhile, the customer acquisition cost for these additional sales is effectively zero.
If you’re not monetizing this moment, you’re leaving money on the table after every single order on your WooCommerce store.
The second order problem is the real killer
Here’s the brutal math most store owners don’t know: between 74 and 85% of first-time buyers never come back.
Bluecore’s 2022 benchmark report analyzed 35.5 billion campaigns across 400+ retail brands and found that 74% of retail customers are one-time buyers who never return. A separate Uptain study of 3,000+ online stores put this figure even higher at over 85%, meaning less than 15% of customers ever place a second order.
This matters because repeat customers are where the money is. Gorgias data from 12,000+ merchants shows repeat buyers represent only 21% of customers but generate 44% of revenue and 46% of orders. Adobe’s research found they’re 9x more likely to convert than first-time shoppers and spend 3x more per visit. Smile.io’s analysis of 1.1 billion shoppers is even more dramatic: 41% of ecommerce revenue comes from just 8% of customers.
Every study you can find will tell you the same thing: acquiring a new customer costs 5 to 25 times more than retaining an existing one. Increasing retention by just 5% increases a typical WooCommerce store’s profits significantly.
The timing window is narrow too. Uptain’s research shows the second purchase typically happens within two weeks of the first. Adobe Commerce analysis identifies six months of inactivity as the typical churn threshold. If a customer was going to return, it’s significantly more likely within that window.
This is why the post-purchase moment is so valuable. You’ve got someone who just bought from you, they’re in a positive emotional state, and you have a brief window to turn them from a one-time buyer into a repeat customer. Most stores waste this opportunity completely.
Why post-purchase works better than interrupting checkout
There are basically three places you can show upsells: in the cart, during checkout, or after purchase. All three can work, but post-purchase has a specific advantage when it comes to popup-style offers.
Cart and checkout upsells carry risk. Every additional friction point between a customer and their purchase is a chance for them to abandon. The Baymard Institute puts average cart abandonment around 70%. Adding popups during checkout can push that number higher.
Post-purchase changes the equation. The sale is already secured. There’s zero risk of cart abandonment because the transaction is complete. And customers are in what behavioral economists call “purchase momentum,” a psychological state where additional buying decisions feel easier.
That elevated emotional state creates a window of receptivity that closes quickly.
Post-purchase also leverages what psychologists call the foot-in-the-door technique. Freedman & Fraser’s landmark 1966 study at Stanford demonstrated this effect: when asked directly to place large “Drive Carefully” signs, only 17% of homeowners agreed. But those first asked to place tiny 3-inch stickers, then later asked for large signs, agreed at 76%, a 4.5x increase from small initial commitments. A completed purchase functions as that small commitment, making customers substantially more open to subsequent offers.
People feel compelled to act consistently with prior commitments, especially those that are active, public, effortful, and freely chosen. All characteristics of a purchase decision.
What the big retailers already know
Amazon generates 35% of total revenue through post-purchase cross-selling with “Frequently bought together” and “Customers who bought this also bought” recommendations. Their Prime upsells appear throughout the checkout and confirmation flow, targeting the 40+ million US Prime members who spend roughly 3x more than non-members.
Sephora is cited by Baymard Institute as a benchmark for post-purchase UX. Their confirmation pages feature app promotion, pop-ups offering discounts on related beauty products with time-limited urgency, and Rewards Bazaar integration for point redemption. The results: 95% of every dollar spent at Sephora comes from Beauty Insider members.
Nike takes an experience-based approach through their app ecosystem spanning Nike App, Run Club, Training Club, and SNKRS. Members receive “surprise drops” triggered by engagement patterns. The strategy has built 100 million members who spend 3x more than non-members, with SNKRS app revenue growing from $70M to $700M in five years.
These companies didn’t discover some secret. They just recognized that the post-purchase moment is prime real estate and invested in capturing it.
The post-purchase conversion numbers are bigger than you think
ReConvert analyzed 40,000+ Shopify merchants and found average thank you page upsell conversion sits at 1.7%, with top performers reaching 6.8-8%. One-click post-purchase upsells averaged 4.7% conversion, with the top 5% of merchants achieving 28.3% and best-in-class implementations hitting 37%.
Focus Digital’s 2025 report analyzing 1,847 businesses broke down conversion by upsell type:
- Order bumps: 37.8%
- One-time offers: 23.4%
- Offer walls: 19.2%
- Post-purchase upsells: 14.6%
- Email sequence upsells: 11.3%
BJJ Fanatics generated $452,288 in extra revenue during Q4 alone through thank you page upsells, with an 11.56% conversion rate driving 8,000+ additional orders.
The ROI is hard to argue with. ReConvert reports merchants see $686 return for every $1 spent on post-purchase optimization, compared to roughly $36 per dollar for standard email marketing. Top stores generate 12.7% of total revenue from post-purchase offers alone, with an average 5.6% AOV uplift across all merchants.
How to capture this in WooCommerce
WooCommerce’s default thank you page is basically useless for conversion. It shows order details and that’s it. No recommendations, no upsells, no way to turn that first purchase into a second.
CheckoutWC includes post-purchase upsell popups that appear as modals after checkout completion. You can configure display rules based on cart contents, order value, product categories, or customer history. The one-click purchase flow means customers can add products without re-entering payment information.
The simplicity of Shopify with the power of WooCommerce. Replace your WooCommerce checkout page with CheckoutWC to boost sales and reduce cart abandonment.
Here’s what setup looks like:
- Navigate to CheckoutWC > Order Bumps and enable the feature
- Create a new order bump and select “After Checkout Submit Modal” as the display location
- Configure your rules engine conditions (show laptop accessories when someone buys a laptop, show the premium version for orders under a certain value, etc.)
- Design the offer with a clear headline and an easy rejection option that’s not pushy
The key is relevance. The best post-purchase offers are directly related to what the customer just bought. A mattress buyer should see mattress protectors, not random products from your catalog. Smart variation matching can automatically match offer attributes to cart contents, so a customer who bought a queen mattress gets offered a queen-size protector.
For detailed setup instructions, see our order bumps documentation and thank you page customization guide.
Add a loyalty program to bring them back again and again
Post-purchase optimization isn’t complicated. The psychology is well-documented across decades of behavioral economics research. The conversion data is clear from millions of transactions. Major retailers have proven the approach at scale.
Most WooCommerce stores still don’t do it because the default setup doesn’t support it and adding the capability requires deliberate effort.
That deliberate effort is worth it. Converting just 5% more first-time buyers into repeat customers can generate nearly $900,000 in additional revenue over two years for a mid-sized retailer. The customers are already there. The moment is already happening. You’re just not capturing it.
CheckoutWC’s order bump feature handles the technical implementation. The strategy is on you: identify the right products to offer, set intelligent display rules, and test what works for your specific customer base.
If the big retailer data has you thinking about membership programs (remember: Sephora and Ulta generate 95% of revenue from loyalty members), the post-purchase moment is also ideal for membership upsells. Constellation lets you create WooCommerce membership programs with recurring billing, member-only pricing, and content restriction. Account Funds for WooCommerce offers a lighter-weight approach with store credit that keep customers coming back. Both integrate with CheckoutWC’s order bump system, so you can offer membership upgrades or store credit top-ups right on the thank you page.
Your thank you page is either working for you or it isn’t. Right now, for most stores, it isn’t.
The simplicity of Shopify with the power of WooCommerce. Replace your WooCommerce checkout page with CheckoutWC to boost sales and reduce cart abandonment.
